MLP - Festivalby =DShouCommentsThank you very much for the critique! Uhm but before putting my vote for fair or not, I feel just a quick reply to confirm a few things is needed if that's okay.
Yea I do see what you mean by the water, it's an error on my part as I've intended to give it a foggy appearance with an inner-innate glow coming from within the water, the location is placed in a more mystical-type land but in the end I wasn't able to portray this from just looking at it. So yea, I agree with that. I'm not sure about the mention of Fluttershy's size, in relation to the drawing, however. Perspective-wise allows her to be up close to the camera, even then I didn't make her too large to clip out of the view, nor too small because I wanted to keep the characters in focus, Fluttershy especially being a key part to the composition. I guess the main point I'm curious about is if you can elaborate on the 'room for improvement', because using that phrase leaves a lot of questions. If that's all you meant, the two things above, then alright that's all. Otherwise, please explain a bit more if that's okay. Sorry, I spoke wrong
The room for improvement refers mainly to the ocean and little bit to RD's anatomy (which I forgot to mention, sorry again!). I don't really know where her body is when I look at her or how she's sitting. Ah yea, the amount of space comparing the two is quite different, I guess my logic was that it would look like a shipping drawing otherwise, I wanted to give a Dashie a bit more distance as well.
Back-view + cloaks = confusion apparently, she's meant to be laying on her back, left-front hoof touching left-hind hoof, right-front hoof being lifted slightly in a natural sense to gaze, but because of the cloak I kinda end up leaving the viewers having to assume =S Alright, thank you again for the critique! Voted fair now thanks to the clarifications. |
Beautiful, but there is room for improvement.